About Simon Express and Simon Free

Did you use Simon Express or Simon Free for the Mac App Store? As you have probably seen by now, they are no longer available. I was unable to update them, so announced back in October last year that I'd remove them, which I did when Simon 4.0 was released.

I thought I'd go into this in a bit more depth today.

So, why wasn't I able to update them?

When the Mac App Store was introduced back in 2011, apps could be included without too many modifications or special requirements. So I was happy to provide special editions of my Simon app, which I called Simon Express and Simon Free. The Express edition enabled unlimited tests (at a time when the standard edition had license limits on the number of tests, which is no longer true), but was streamlined to only provide a basic set of services, filters and notifiers, without the ability to add or edit them. Simon Express sold for $59.99. Simon Free was the same, but was limited to only a few tests, and available at no cost. These seemed like useful editions for people who didn't need the full power of the standard edition, and preferred the convenience of the Mac App Store.

But as of June 2012, Apple threw a spanner in the works: they required that all apps in the Mac App Store be “sandboxed” — where the apps can only access their own private folder, among other restrictions.

Since Simon is a powerful tool, capable to monitoring arbitrary folders, accessing network services, running customizable scripts, etc, it wasn't feasible to sandbox Simon without cutting out a lot of functionality, which I didn't want to do. Even the cut-down Express and Free editions would have had to be severely restricted. So it just wasn't doable.

For a couple of years, I left the Express and Free editions on the store, without updates, but I felt bad about them falling behind the standard edition, and so when version 4 came along, it was time to retire those editions.

But where does that leave people who bought the Express edition?

If that's you, you are of course welcome to continue using it (or the Free edition) for as long as you like. But to take advantage of the attractive new user interface and enhanced features of version 4, you'll need a Simon 4 license.

I didn't want to make you have to buy a full license, though. So in version 4 I added support for treating Simon Express as a full version 3 license. If you have Simon Express installed (or have previously used it with your Mac), a “Simon Express” item will automatically appear in Simon's Licenses window. So all you need to buy is a Simon Upgrade license.

Furthermore, if you don't already have data for the standard edition, Simon 4 will automatically recognize and import your Simon Express data, enabling a smooth transition from the old app.

In the months since removing the Mac App Store editions, I don't recall having received any negative feedback about this move. I think most people understand... and frankly the Mac App Store editions were never huge sellers; most people preferred the power and flexibility of the standard edition.

The Mac App Store is a useful tool for discovery of apps that fit within Apple's rulebook, but some apps like Simon, and other third-party ones like BBEdit, Coda and more don't fit in that model. And that's fine.

I will continue to include my apps in the Mac App Store when I can... while also selling directly from the Dejal site.